PitchJuryJudge pitches

Rules

What belongs here, what does not, and what happens to a pitch once it is up.

What this is

A public library of outreach templates — cold emails, LinkedIn DMs, recruiter messages, sales follow-ups — rated by anyone. The score is the point: it tells you which messages actually land.

Submitting is free. Every submission is read by a person before it appears, usually within a day.

PitchJury is operated by Prospera Technologies FZ-LLC, a UAE company. For removal requests and anything else: wabil@prospera-technologies.com.

What you may submit

A real message you actually sent. Not something written for the board, and not something generated.

Do not submit messages containing another person's real name, email address, phone number, or company. Anonymise before submitting — replace them with placeholders such as [first name] or name@company.com. Submissions that republish someone else's contact details are rejected.

Limits: title 80 characters, message 2000, context 300.

Your own contact details

The name and link you add to your own listing are public by design — that is what makes a good template double as a portfolio piece.

One link only, and it must start with https://. You may keep your own query parameters — including your own utm_source, so you can see in your analytics which clicks came from here. Parameters whose value is another URL are removed, because those turn any link into a redirect to somewhere we never checked.

If you do not add your own, we append utm_source=pitchjury.net to outbound clicks so the traffic is attributable either way. Short links are resolved to their destination, and one that cannot be resolved is not accepted. Chat and invite links, adult and gambling sites, and known malware domains are refused. Outbound links carry nofollow, so this is not a place to buy backlinks. A listing whose link breaks these rules is removed.

Voting

Templates are voted on publicly, and scores can go down. Clicking the same button again removes your vote; clicking the other one switches it.

One vote per network per pitch — not per browser. Everyone sharing an internet connection shares a single vote on each pitch, and opening a private window does not get you another one. On an office or campus connection that means the first person to vote votes for everybody there. That is the deliberate trade: the alternative is that anyone can push their own pitch up the board as fast as they can open new windows, and then the percentage is worth nothing.

Votes are deduplicated without storing IP addresses. Your address is hashed with a secret salt inside the request that handles your vote and is never written to a database, a log, or any response. The hash cannot be reversed into an address.

Every pitch shows its verdict count beside the percentage. A pitch at 100% from two votes and one at 100% from two hundred are not the same claim, and the count is there so you can tell them apart at a glance. The figure appears from the first verdict; before anyone has judged, it says so.

The breakdown of why people said no waits for ten verdicts. One tally against each of ten reasons, drawn from a single opinion, is not an explanation — it is a bar chart of one person.

Prohibited content

Submissions are rejected if they contain any of the following:

Editing and removal

A submission is final. Once you send it there is no way to edit it and no way to withdraw it yourself — there are no accounts here and no private link. Read it over before you submit, and if you want to change something, put up a new one.

To ask for something to be removed, use the contact link on the listing, or the address below.

Contact

Removal requests and anything else: wabil@prospera-technologies.com.

PitchJury is operated by Prospera Technologies FZ-LLC, a UAE company.